Japanese anime, the most popular characteristic of Japan,
is the direct way for people all over the world to learn Japanese and their culture.
Indeed some scholars suggest defining anime as a quintessentially Japanese may
be related to a new form of orientalism. As the most necessary industry in
Japan, the animation product in Japan generally expand in a wide domain. We cannot see the popularity of manga and
completeness of animation system in other country as same as Japan. Recalling
all Japanese anime I saw in the class, Patlabor movie and Ghost in the shell are
my favorable anime in series of mecha anime. At the first glance of both anime,
I feel unbelievable to see the published date. The theme and general style of
both anime should able to exist during 21th century. And both anime are created
by Oshii Mamoru. Especially, Patlabor II shows Japanese society and culture with a complicated backgroud. So I choose to compare Patlabor movie 2 and movies 3 which are
the most famous work of Oshii Mamoru and analyze the main idea of Genius
Oshii.
In
Patlabor III, technologic machine was totally abandoned by Oshii. It is just
appeared in the beginning and last sense. The story happens in 2000, a series
of unknown attacks on Labors have led to two police detectives, Shinichiro Hata
and Takeshi Kusumi. After they were attack by an unknown monster, they were
searching for the reason of existence of that monster. There is a female
scientist who created a biological special live which is made of the cancer cell
from her daughter. As they begin to unravel the mystery behind the attacks, the
two detectives find reason to suspect that the attacks may have something to do
with the American military stationed in Japan, elements of the Japanese Ground
Self-Defense Forces. In the end, the members in section 2 appear to help detective to
use specific music to attract monster and kill it. The female scientist kills
herself with the secret of GSDF and American military also was disappeared when
the monster died. To compare with second one, Oshii imply the issue between
Japanese government and American military more obscured. Indeed, this issue is
caused by GSDF and American military. Oshii like forces his motif on conflict
between Japanese society and American government. As we know, after Japan's defeat in World War
II, Japan has to accept the peace constitution which written from the
perspective of the United States. In that constitution, the government banned
to own a regular army. They can only be set a limited self-defense forces. Some
people think that this article greatly affect the autonomy of country. Oshii
shows his strong will on the political issue and let more people realizes this
problems.
Approach
from the production part, Oshii’s style always be cold and real. I feel the
real life of Japan in his artwork. His work always base on the reality of
everything. Whatever the characters in the movie and city feature, he all use
the local Japanese mode rather than western background. Furthermore, comparing
with other mecha anime, the music background of patlabor always be a circulated
and weird melody instead of a popular song. Oshii makes anime closer to a
movie. He pays a lot of attention on characters' mood and logic details. For
example, in second patlabor, they safe place to share secret is a moving vehicle.
And in third patlabor, the detective talks with his partner in a moving sky
wheel. The idea explosion is more important than exaggerate and fancy elements in his work.
It is the thing I really adore.
You give a really good overview of both Patlabor 2 and Patlabor 3, covering their themes and goals in a detailed, analytical way. You said that "Arakawa also said that war is always not reality and so far all the war is not a real." That interested me because I would argue that even though it was a staged war with minimalized casualties, it was a war. It caused major fear and disrupted Tokyo's infrastructure despite the fact that Tsuge was just trying to alert them to the fact that Tokyo's peace was an illusion. Although I haven't seen Patlabor 3, I am now very interested to see it, particularly since you say it kind of goes away from the Mecha in a similar way to how Patlabor 2 moves away from the mecha compared to the Patlabor television series. Comparatively, did you think that Patlabor 3 held to many of same themes and messages as Patlabor 2?
回复删除Yes. In my mind, Oshii's movie leads audience finally too see his theme which is focus on the politic issue behind the peace life. In Patlabor 3, he uses the chemical monster to replace the terrorists in Patlabor 2. But that monster is caused by American military. As you mention the major fear and disrupted Tokyo's infrastructure in Patlabor 2 are still exist in Patlabor 3. The police office and section 2 just give a temporary solution for those potential safety hazard in Tokyo. So in Patlabor, the safety issue appears in another kind of form.
删除The theme of the hyper reality that gets highlighted in Patlabor 2 and I guess in 3 seems very unique for the mecha genre. Specifically how again in Patlabor 3 you say they mainly don't use the labors, it's much more about the actual people and what they do. The idea you showed of how it like uses the labors as a way to show more what people are. All around your analysis of the two films showed a lot of depth and thoughtful themes that I didn't get from just watching Patlabor 2.
回复删除As I mention in the second paragraph, oshii regards the mecha genre as a tool. He didn't show much for us about the close relationship between policeman and mecha as same as the Gensis and EVA. The Patlabor for policeman in section 2 is as same as the guns and cars for policeman nowadays. I don't mean mecha is not important in Patlabor 3. Patlabor plays a necessary role in third movie which help normal policeman to kill the monster. Oshii just regards them as a normal technology in people's life. But that may be the specific way for Oshii to show mecha's importance.
删除